Pros Talking Prose

What happens when readers discover that the book they loved was written by AI? Does the story suddenly become less valuable—or does the author lose something far more important: the reader's trust?
AI-generated books are becoming part of the publishing conversation, but authors and readers aren't necessarily seeing eye to eye. And while some writers are embracing artificial intelligence as a shortcut to publishing faster, readers may be questioning what they're actually paying for.
This week on Pros Talking Prose, Stacey and Troy tackle a slightly uncomfortable question: Is AI turning authorship into the creative equivalent of wearing a fake Rolex? Yes, we're talking counterfeit luxury watches, Burberry, AI-generated music, influencer culture, and what any of those things have to do with writing books. Trust us, there's a connection.
We're not anti-AI. In fact, we both recognize how useful it can be in an author business. But there's a big difference between using AI to support your creativity and allowing it to replace the very thing readers come to you for. When readers start questioning whether the creativity they're buying is genuine, authors have a much bigger problem than a few awkward sentences.
We're digging into reader perception, AI writing, author credibility, authenticity, and why the choices you make today could influence your relationship with readers for years to come. A book isn't just a product. There's a human being behind the story, or at least readers expect there to be.
Whether you're an indie author, traditionally published author, aspiring writer, or publishing professional, this is a conversation worth having.
What do you think?
Does knowing a book was written by AI change how you feel about it? And where do you draw the line between AI-assisted writing and AI-generated books? We'd love to hear your thoughts in the comments. Even if you disagree with us. Especially if you disagree with us!

00:00 – Fake Rolexes, Luxury Brands, and a Strange Connection to Writing
08:20 – Why Readers Are Rejecting AI-Written Books
11:52 – Is AI Writing the Counterfeit Rolex of Publishing?
15:12 – Why Knowing Something Is AI-Generated Changes Its Value
20:34 – AI Writing, Imposter Syndrome, and Author Credibility
31:57 – What Burberry Can Teach Authors About Authenticity
37:56 – What Makes a Story Genuinely Human?
44:28 – Why Authenticity Matters to Readers
52:47 – When AI Becomes a Shortcut Instead of a Tool
1:01:20 – Can Editors and Readers Recognize AI Writing?
1:04:12 – Protecting Your Manuscript and Your Creative Voice
1:09:50 – Why Every Author Should Have an AI Policy

Join Us at Wayfinder Summit!
October 15–17, 2026 | Virtual Author Retreat
Less Distraction. More Direction.
Three days dedicated to helping authors find clarity, build sustainable writing and publishing practices, and make real progress toward their goals. Join Stacey, Troy, Becca Syme, Roland Denzel, and other industry professionals for a retreat built around doing the work, not just talking about it. https://wayfinder-summit.heysummit.com/

Resources Mentioned
Becca Syme — Better-Faster Academy
https://betterfasteracademy.com/
Dear Writer, You Need to Quit — Becca Syme
https://betterfasteracademy.com/books-by-becca-syme/dear-writer-you-need-to-quit/
Story Genius — Lisa Cron
https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/252747/story-genius-by-lisa-cron/

Connect With Us
Print to Pro — Publishing Strategy, Education & Author Services
https://printtopro.com/
P2P Author Business Harbor — Our Author Community
https://www.skool.com/p2p-author-business-harbor

Join us for more candid conversations, publishing guidance, author-business resources, and opportunities to connect with other writers.
If you're enjoying Pros Talking Prose, please like, subscribe, and share the episode with another author. It helps us reach more writers and keep these conversations going.

Music Credits
Music: Suppermassive Black Hole
Artist/Composer: Muse

About Pros Talking Prose
Join publishing professionals Stacey Smekofske and Troy Lambert as they talk writing, editing, publishing, book marketing, and the business of being an author. No magic formulas, no sugarcoating, and occasionally a few rabbit holes along the way.
Keep writing. Be kind. Stay weird.

#ProsTalkingProse #AIWriting #AIWrittenBooks #WritingCommunity #IndieAuthors #SelfPublishing #AuthorBusiness #ArtificialIntelligence

Could thinking about book sales before you finish your manuscript actually keep you from finishing it?

You want to write a great book. You also want someone to buy the thing. But when should target readers, genre expectations, and book marketing enter the conversation?

This week on Pros Talking Prose, Stacey Smekofske and Troy Lambert get a little feisty about where writing craft meets author business. Stacey makes the case for helping authors understand their book’s market potential early. Troy asks whether that same information can interrupt the creative process, create pressure, or send a perfectly good story in the wrong direction.

Naturally, we debate it like reasonable adults. With a house of cards, a few musical detours, and the occasional “just write the damn story.”

From manuscript reviews and developmental editing to author platforms, writing anxiety, and protecting your writing time, we explore a question that matters to new writers and experienced indie authors alike: How do you build a publishing business without getting in the way of the book you’re trying to write?

Tell us what you think: Would knowing your book’s target audience and market potential help you revise—or make you overthink every sentence?

Follow Pros Talking Prose for candid conversations about writing, editing, self-publishing, book marketing, and building a sustainable author career.

CHAPTERS

00:00 A friendly publishing debate gets feisty
03:14 When should authors think about book marketability?
10:37 Can market expectations derail your story?
20:07 Author goals, manuscript revisions, and reader expectations
27:16 When should you build your author platform?
33:30 How publishing pressure can keep you from writing
40:32 Protecting creativity from the pressure to sell
46:36 How to protect your writing time and find your flow
52:04 When is an author ready for publishing advice?
1:00:07 Why writing advice depends on the author
1:03:50 Wayfinder Summit, Preptober, and upcoming author classes

LINKS & RESOURCES

• Print to Pro: Editing, manuscript reviews, publishing guidance, and author business resources
https://printtopro.com/

• Print to Pro Power Sessions: Class schedule and registration, including the distribution session discussed in this episode
https://printtopro.com/powersessions-2026/

• Troy Lambert / The Plot Dude: Writing courses, manuscript evaluations, and story resources
https://theplotabides.com/

• The Plot Dude’s Craft Lab: Monthly writing webinars, including October’s Preptober session
https://theplotabides.com/webinars/

• Wayfinder Summit: A virtual working retreat for authors—less distraction, more direction
https://wayfindersummit.com/

Be kind. Keep writing. Stay weird.

#WritingCommunity #SelfPublishing #AuthorBusiness

There’s a LOT of writing and publishing advice out there. Follow this formula. Use this tool. Publish this way. Market your book like this, but after 100 episodes of Pros Talking Prose, we keep coming back to two words: It depends.

In our 100th episode, we hand the conversation over to you. We answer questions from our listeners about writing, editing, AI, indie vs. traditional publishing, staying focused long enough to actually write the damn book, series writing, the books every writer should read, and what we’ve learned from 100 episodes of talking about the publishing industry.

We also revisit some of our favorite moments, arguments, guests, questionable conversations, and lessons from the show, including a few things we’ve changed our minds about along the way.

Because whether you’re trying to improve your writing craft, decide how to publish your book, build an author business, use AI responsibly, market your work, or figure out which piece of author advice you should actually listen to, there usually isn’t one universal answer.

Your goals matter.
Your circumstances matter.
You and your story are what matters.

So come celebrate 100 episodes with us (not with a greatest-hits clip show) with the kind of messy, funny, occasionally inappropriate, real-world conversation that got us here in the first place. And thank you for being the fly on the wall for 100 episodes. We’re not done yet.

Follow us for more at PrintToPro.com
Join us at the Wayfinder Summit Writers Retreat October 15th. 
https://WayfinderSummit.com

Pros Talking Prose is a couple of working publishing and editing professionals talking about the information that authors really want to know. The real-life stuff.

Chapters
00:00 100 Episodes of Writing, Publishing & Friendship
09:18 How AI Has Changed Writing and Publishing
14:35 Can AI Replace a Professional Book Editor?
35:04 Books Every Writer Should Read
56:22 Indie Publishing vs. Traditional Publishing: Where Should Authors Start?
1:16:17 How Writers Can Stop Distractions and Actually Write
1:24:40 The Biggest Mistakes Authors Make With Book Two
1:27:46 What 100 Episodes Taught Us About Writing and Publishing
1:36:05 The Truth About Writing Advice: It Depends

#WritingAdvice #PublishingAdvice #IndiePublishing #SelfPublishing #WritingPodcast #AuthorBusiness #BookMarketing #WritingTips #Authors #ProsTalkingProse

Book marketing has changed, and a lot of the advice authors are still following was built for an internet that doesn’t really exist anymore.

In this episode of Pros Talking Prose, we sit down with marketing strategist Amanda Natividad, founder of Zero Click Marketing, Chief Evangelist at SparkToro, and co-author with Rand Fishkin of the upcoming book Zero Click Marketing: How to Build Brands and Earn Customers on a Traffic-Starved Web.

We talk about what authors should be doing when Google sends fewer clicks, social media platforms want to keep people on-platform, AI tools are changing how people search, and traditional marketing attribution doesn’t always tell us where readers actually discovered us. And no, the answer is NOT “be everywhere.”

Amanda walks us through how authors can figure out where their readers are already spending time, choose the right discovery platform, create content that actually connects to their books and brand, and stop letting algorithms dictate their entire marketing strategy.

We also get into author websites, newsletters, blogs, direct sales, audience research, personal vs. author social media accounts, AI-generated content, going viral without making money, and why sometimes the best marketing goal isn’t an immediate sale.
As Amanda puts it: “Find more meaning in your marketing beyond just the sales.”

Oh, and somehow the Black Plague becomes a legitimate book marketing case study. Because apparently that’s where we are now. 
If you’re an indie author, self-published author, traditionally published author, or authorpreneur trying to figure out what book marketing looks like in 2026, this conversation will give you plenty to think about.

CHAPTERS
00:00 – Welcome to Pros Talking Prose
03:55 – What Is Zero Click Marketing?
06:12 – Why Traditional SEO and Website Traffic Have Changed
10:43 – How Authors Can Find Where Their Readers Actually Are
15:54 – Audience Research and Smarter Book Marketing
20:18 – Do Author Websites and Email Lists Still Matter?
22:08 – Are Blogs Still Worth It in the Age of AI Search?
26:15 – Why Book Marketing Attribution Is Broken
29:35 – Why Author Brand Recognition Matters More Than Ever
31:14 – What “Providing Value” Actually Means for Authors
32:03 – Yes, the Black Plague Becomes a Marketing Strategy
33:52 – Should Authors Have Separate Social Media Accounts?
38:01 – How Your Own Social Media Behavior Affects Discovery
41:16 – Amanda’s Own Book Publishing and Direct Sales Strategy
48:29 – Are Authors Giving Algorithms Too Much Power?
51:55 – Authenticity vs. Valuable Content: What Matters More?
57:06 – Why Author Newsletters Still Matter
58:49 – Marketing Advice That Makes Amanda Want to Throw Something
01:04:30 – Amanda’s #1 Book Marketing Advice: Pick ONE Platform
01:06:30 – Where to Find Amanda + Zero Click Marketing

LINKS & RESOURCES
Amanda Natividad
https://amandanat.com/
Zero Click Marketing
https://zeroclickmarketing.co/
Zero Click Marketing: The Book
https://zeroclickmarketing.co/book
SparkToro – Audience Research
https://sparktoro.com/
The Menu Newsletter
Find it through Amanda’s website:
https://amandanat.com/
Wayfinder Summit
https://wayfindersummit.com/
Print to Pro
https://printtopro.com

ABOUT PROS TALKING PROSE
Pros Talking Prose is where we talk honestly about writing, publishing, book marketing, author business, and what it actually takes to build a sustainable career around your books. No magic formulas. No pretending every author needs the same marketing plan. Just real conversations about writing better books, reaching readers, and building an author business that actually works.
Subscribe and join us for a new conversation every week.

#bookmarketingtips #AuthorMarketing #AuthorPlatform #IndieAuthors #SelfPublishing #ZeroClickMarketing #BookMarketingTips #AuthorBusiness #WritingCommunity #SocialMediaMarketing

Authors spend a lot of time worrying about book sales, reviews, algorithms, trends, AI, bestseller lists, agents, publishers, other authors’ success… and a whole lot of things we can’t control.

All that noise can make it very easy to lose your way.

In this episode of Pros Talking Prose, Troy and Stacey talk about the difference between the things authors can control, the things they can influence, and the things they may need to simply be aware of… and let go.

There is no magic formula for author success.
You can control the work you do, the choices you make, and how you show up in your author career. You can influence things like sales, reviews, opportunities, and visibility, but you can’t guarantee the outcome. When authors spend too much energy chasing algorithms, trends, bestseller status, or what everyone else is doing, those things can start controlling them.

If you're an indie author, self-published author, traditionally published author, or writer building a sustainable author business, this conversation is for you.

RESOURCES

Wayfinder Summit — A Virtual Working Retreat for Authors
Less Distraction. More Direction.
https://wayfindersummit.com

Beyond Author Scams: Protect Yourself & Your Author Business
Free live class — September 23
https://learning.printtopro.com/beyondauthorscams/

The Author Platform Operating Plan — Power Session
Learn how to build and nurture an author platform around the parts you can actually control.
https://learning.printtopro.com/p2p-power-session-september-session/

Plot Dude Craft Lab: Character-Driven vs. Plot-Driven Fiction
September 22 with Troy Lambert
https://learning.printtopro.com/character-driven-vs-plot-driven-fiction/

Better-Faster Academy — Becca Syme Events
We mention Becca’s upcoming Boise workshop in October.
https://classes.betterfasteracademy.com/courses/23dfb71c-aa32-47e9-bacf-88b7e4eeaa38/salespage

Pros Talking Prose is the place where publishing professionals Stacey Smekofske and Troy Lambert talk shop about writing craft, indie publishing, author business, book marketing, publishing trends, AI for authors, and what it really takes to build a sustainable writing career.
No magic formulas. No guaranteed bestseller promises. Just real conversations about writing, publishing, and the business of being an author. If that sounds like your kind of weird, subscribe and join us each Saturday.Keep writing. Be kind. Stay weird.

CHAPTERS
00:00 The Mystery Noise We Couldn't Control
03:29 What Authors Can—and Can't—Control
10:01 Why There Is No Formula for Author Success
21:37 Book Sales, Reviews & What Authors Can Influence
27:43 Your Author Reputation Is Something You CAN Control
42:06 When Worry Starts Controlling Your Author Career
48:26 Algorithms, Trends & the Fear of Falling Behind
57:36 AI, Search & the Changing Publishing Industry
1:23:15 Stop Worrying About What Doesn't Matter
1:29:37 Don't Lose Your Way

#authorbusiness  #IndieAuthor #SelfPublishing #WritingCommunity #BookMarketing #AuthorLife #WritingMotivation #Publishing #WritingTips #ProsTalkingProse

Readers aren’t accepting “good enough” books anymore.

The quality bar in publishing has moved, and whether you publish independently, traditionally, or somewhere in between, readers are paying attention.

In this episode, Stacey and Troy dig into what “professional quality” actually means today. Spoiler: professional means more than editing.

A strong book is not just grammatically clean. The story must work. The cover must communicate the right promise. The formatting needs to disappear into the reading experience. Your genre expectations matter. Your presentation matters. And increasingly, readers can tell when an author has skipped the learning, rushed the process, or relied on technology to make decisions they weren’t equipped to evaluate.

We also talk about how AI is raising the minimum quality floor without necessarily creating better books. AI can help create something passable, but if an author doesn’t understand story craft, cover design, editing, formatting, or reader expectations, “passable” may be exactly where the book stays.

And readers are looking for more than passable.

Ultimately, publishing professionally comes down to respecting the person on the other side of the book. Readers are investing their money, but more importantly, they are investing their time. Your job is to make that investment worthwhile.

In this episode, we discuss:

• Why the publishing quality bar keeps rising
• Why AI can produce mediocrity surprisingly well
• The difference between copy editing, developmental editing, and manuscript evaluation
• Why readers notice poor covers and formatting—even when they can’t explain what feels wrong
• Why learning your craft still matters, regardless of the tools you use
• How genre expectations create a reader promise
• Why professional publishing is really about building reader trust
• The four things a professional book should accomplish

As Stacey puts it near the end of the conversation: readers are not obligated to support your writing journey. Your responsibility is to give them an experience worth investing in.

RESOURCES & LINKS MENTIONED

Wayfinder Summit — A Virtual Working Retreat for Authors
Three days of focused work, community, professional guidance, networking, and practical support for authors who want to make meaningful progress. Registration begins at $30.
https://WayfinderSummit.com

P2P Author Business Harbor
Join the conversation with other writers and publishing professionals inside our author community.
https://www.skool.com/p2p-author-business-harbor/about

Editing Services / Manuscript Evaluations
Not sure whether your manuscript needs developmental editing, substantive editing, copy editing, or something else? Stacey breaks down the different editorial services and what each one is designed to accomplish.
https://PrintToPro.com

Russell Nohelty
We reference Russell’s discussion about AI writing and his argument that one of the biggest problems with AI-assisted writing is using the technology before developing the craft and judgment necessary to guide it.
https://www.hapitalist.com/cv/

If you enjoy conversations about the realities of writing, publishing, author business, craft, AI, and the constantly changing publishing industry, subscribe and join us each week for Pros Talking Prose.

Keep writing. Stay weird. Be kind.

#WritingCommunity #IndieAuthors #SelfPublishing #BookPublishing #WritingCraft #AuthorBusiness #BookEditing #PublishingTips #AIWriting

 

Writing may happen alone, but building an author career doesn’t.

After a whirlwind weekend at Killer Nashville, Stacey and Troy came home thinking about something that doesn’t get talked about nearly enough in publishing: the people you surround yourself with can fundamentally change the direction of your career.

A conversation with a stranger can become a friendship. A friendship can become an introduction. An introduction can lead to an editor, agent, publisher, printer, collaborator, client, or simply another writer who understands exactly what this strange career feels like.
In this episode of Pros Talking Prose, we talk about what healthy professional relationships actually look like in the publishing industry, and where those relationships can go wrong.

We get into networking without making it feel transactional, building genuine connections at writers’ conferences, maintaining professional boundaries with editors and clients, following up when someone gives you an opportunity, and why knowing someone should never mean ignoring the proper process.

We also talk candidly about the author-editor relationship. Can your editor also be your friend? Absolutely. But friendship can complicate criticism, invoices, boundaries, and those difficult conversations every good editor eventually has to have.

And sometimes, the most important relationship you build has nothing to do with what that person can do for your career.
Sometimes you simply need people in your corner.
Because authors are not competing for one tiny piece of the publishing world. We are colleagues navigating many of the same challenges, and learning how to support, recommend, celebrate, and connect with one another can make this career a whole lot less lonely.

Go to https://WayfinderSummit.com to join us at our writers' retreat in October. 
Find us at https://printtopro.com
You can also go to our community at https://www.skool.com/p2p-author-business-harbor/about

Chapters

00:00 – Back from Killer Nashville
02:00 – How Important Are Relationships in Publishing?
13:00 – How Relationships Open Doors for Authors
19:00 – Networking, Reputation & Professional Boundaries
28:00 – Publishing Companies, Printers & the Power of Real Connections
43:00 – Should You Be Friends With Your Editor?
1:07:00 – Stop Treating Other Authors Like Competition
1:13:00 – Why Writers Need Community

If you’re an indie author, traditionally published author, aspiring writer, editor, publisher, or simply trying to figure out how to build a sustainable author career, subscribe to Pros Talking Prose. Every week, Stacey and Troy talk candidly about writing craft, publishing, book marketing, author business, editing, AI, and what it actually takes to stay in this industry for the long haul.
#WritingCommunity #AuthorLife #IndieAuthor #Publishing #WritingTips #BookPublishing #AuthorBusiness #WritersConference #BookEditing #ProsTalkingProse

Publishing is changing fast. AI is changing faster. Authors are being told to write more, publish more, build bigger platforms, learn new technology, follow every trend—and somehow keep producing better books while doing it all.

No wonder so many writers feel like they’re losing ground.

In this episode, Stacey and Troy talk about the pressure authors are putting on themselves, why imposter syndrome becomes so dangerous when it mixes with comparison and fear, and why the constant race to keep up may be hurting both your writing and your author career.

We also dig into the growing anxiety surrounding AI, including concerns about AI-generated writing, transparency, Claude and AI watermarking, and the fear some authors have of being “found out” for using these tools.

But this conversation isn't really about whether AI is good or bad, instead we think it's about knowing where your line is, being honest about the way you work, and refusing to let someone else's choices (or the latest publishing panic) determine whether you believe you're a legitimate writer. Because there is no race.

Writing faster doesn't automatically make you more successful. Publishing more books doesn't automatically make you a better author. And chasing every new tool, strategy, controversy, or algorithm change can pull your attention away from the one thing that still matters: Writing a damn good story.

We talk about slowing down, developing your craft, using tools intentionally, finding a writing community that supports you, and why patience and focus may become two of the most valuable skills an author can develop in the next few years.

Wayfinder Summit: Our virtual working retreat for authors focused on clarity, community, productivity, and actually making progress on your work.
https://WayfinderSummit.com

We'd love to hear from you:

Do you ever feel like you're falling behind as an author? What exactly makes you feel that way? Tell us in the comments.

And if you know another writer who needs to hear this today, send this episode their way.

#WritingCommunity #AuthorLife #WritingAdvice #ImposterSyndrome #WritingMotivation #AIForAuthors #SelfPublishing #WritingCraft #IndieAuthors #authors